The Reviewer of the Month for September 2026: Liliana Luca

7 September 2026

Peer review plays a vital role in helping biomedical research move from promising results to reliable scientific communication. Reviewers assess whether studies are clearly described, appropriately interpreted, and useful beyond idealized research settings. Each month, Biomolecules and Biomedicine recognizes a reviewer whose work stands out for being thorough, constructive, and punctual. Through our Reviewer of the Month series, we highlight the expertise and professional care that support trustworthy scientific publishing.

Reviewer of the Month September 2026

Biomolecules and Biomedicine is pleased to recognize Liliana Luca, lecturer at the Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, Ștefan cel Mare University of Suceava, within the Medical Equipment and Systems study program, as our Reviewer of the Month for September 2026.

Liliana Luca is also a specialist medical biologist at Policlinica Bethesda, a private medical laboratory in Suceava, Romania. Her research interests focus on preventive medicine and maintaining a healthy lifestyle through the use of natural resources.

ORCID: 0009-0005-7827-652X

Interview with Liliana Luca

What is one scientific question in your field that you believe researchers should be asking more often, but currently do not?

I think we should ask more often whether the equipment and methods we validate in the lab actually work just as well in real, everyday clinical conditions. It is easy to get good results in a controlled setting, but the question “will this still work at the patient’s bedside, with tired staff and limited time?” does not get asked enough.

When reviewing a manuscript, how do you evaluate whether the authors have presented their methods and results in a way that allows readers to trust and reproduce the work?

I check whether the authors described the steps clearly enough that I, or someone else in the field, could repeat the experiment without guessing details. I look at whether technical parameters, equipment, and conditions are stated concretely, not just mentioned in passing.

What makes a manuscript’s discussion section convincing to you, especially when authors are interpreting complex or preliminary findings?

For me, honesty matters most: whether the authors acknowledge the limitations of their own data and do not draw bigger conclusions than the results support. Especially with preliminary findings, I appreciate when they clearly say “this is just a first step” instead of overstating things.

How do you approach reviewer recommendations when a manuscript is promising, but requires substantial improvement before it can be considered publishable?

I try to clearly separate what is essential to fix from what is just a suggestion. I phrase recommendations so authors understand exactly what needs to change and why, like a colleague trying to help the paper improve, not criticizing for its own sake.

What is one lesson from your own research experience that has shaped the way you review manuscripts for other scientists?

From my own experience, I learned how easy it is to misinterpret a result when you are too attached to your initial hypothesis. Since then, when I review other people’s work, I pay attention to whether they too have left room for alternative interpretations of their data.

Key takeaways for authors and reviewers

Liliana Luca emphasizes that research quality should be tested not only in controlled laboratory settings, but also against the realities of everyday clinical practice. This perspective is especially relevant for studies involving medical equipment, laboratory methods, and clinical workflows, where performance at the bedside may differ from performance under ideal conditions.

For authors, her advice is direct and practical: methods should be detailed enough to allow reproducibility, technical parameters should be clearly reported, and conclusions should not exceed the strength of the evidence. A convincing discussion section is not one that makes the strongest possible claim, but one that honestly explains what the data show, what they do not show, and what remains uncertain.

For reviewers, Liliana Luca highlights the value of separating essential revisions from optional suggestions. The most helpful peer-review comments are clear, specific, and constructive — guiding authors toward a stronger manuscript while preserving the study’s original contribution.

Thank you to our peer reviewers

It is a privilege to recognize Liliana Luca as our Reviewer of the Month for September 2026 and to highlight the thoughtful expertise she brings to peer review. We thank her — and all of our reviewers — for their time, rigor, and constructive feedback, which help uphold the quality and integrity of biomedical research.